Debate

Why the Church allows separation and prohibits divorce

La separación y el divorcio civil no disuelven el vínculo de un matrimonio válido, mientras que la nulidad declara que ese vínculo nunca llegó a existir.

Alejandro Vázquez-Dodero-6 de October de 2026-Reading time: 2 minutes
divorce

Saint Matthew in his Gospel records the well-known “What God has joined together, let no one separate.”(cf. Mt 19:6). These are the words of Christ himself, and they mean that whoever enters into marriage before God creates a permanent, indissoluble bond with his spouse. 

Therefore, even if spouses may stop living together under certain circumstances, they remain married. This is why a separated but legally married person cannot remarry.

Separation as a legitimate exceptional situation

The Catholic Church is a mother, and therefore permits the separation of spouses, which, as the Catechism states, can be legitimate in certain cases provided for by Canon Law. In what cases? When cohabitation becomes seriously difficult or even dangerous, such as when one spouse poses a grave spiritual or physical risk to the other or to the children, or makes life together excessively and disproportionately burdensome.

In these cases, separating may be morally necessary, especially when it is the way to protect people.

And what about civil divorce?

Given the above, it is understood that, from a Catholic perspective, civil divorce can declare that the civil effects of marital cohabitation have ceased, but it cannot by itself produce the disappearance of the bond that arose from a valid marriage.

Therefore, marital breakdown and marriage annulment are not the same. If a truly valid marriage was celebrated and subsequently failed, the Church maintains that this failure does not render the marriage null. 

There can be separation, as we said, and even civil divorce, when necessary to protect rights, children, assets, etc. But the bond –sacramental– remains; the marriage does not disappear.

It is a different matter if there are reasons to believe that the marriage never validly existed, in which case a declaration of nullity can be requested. The Church does not “divorce” the person, but rather declares, after the corresponding process, that a valid marital bond never existed from the beginning.

Read more
La Brújula Newsletter Leave us your email and receive every week the latest news curated with a catholic point of view.