Voting: It is one of our most important responsibilities as citizens. In fact, the Church teaches that there are three primary responsibilities for all citizens: to pay taxes, to defend their country, and to vote.
Each of these responsibilities requires us to put the good of society and our fellow citizens before our individual desires and needs. Therefore, a fundamental question we must answer as Catholic voters is whether the needs of the weakest and most vulnerable are being met. At the ballot box, we have a privileged opportunity to contribute to our nation and promote the common good by applying the values and teachings of our faith to the problems facing our society.
Below you will find a frequently asked questions section about voting for Catholics.
Does the church tell me who to vote for?
No. The Church does not tell us who to vote for when we enter the voting booth. It does not endorse any official slate of candidates or tell Catholics which party to join. Instead, Catholics should use their own judgment and follow their conscience when applying the teachings of our Lord Jesus Christ and the core values of the faith to the decisions they make when voting.
As Catholics, on our demanding path of discipleship, we must evaluate issues and candidates in light of our Catholic faith. Then, we are invited to live out our faith by actively participating: voting and engaging in other civic activities.
How does my Catholic faith help me make these decisions?
From an early age, we are taught to form our conscience in the light of Catholic doctrine. «Following one’s conscience» is often misunderstood as allowing us to do whatever we want, or as following our «gut feeling» that something is right or wrong.
But our faith teaches us that «conscience is the voice of God that resounds in the human heart, revealing the truth to us and calling us to do good and to reject evil» (from the 2015 document of the US bishops «Forming Consciences for Faithful Citizenship,» 17, hereafter referred to as FC).
As Catholics, it is our responsibility to form our conscience by developing the virtue of prudence to discern the true good in the circumstances and choose the appropriate means to achieve it, maintaining the will and openness to seek what is right through the study of Scripture and the teaching of the Church, using our reason to study key issues in light of this teaching, and seeking in prayer to understand God's will.
What about the separation of church and state? Can the Church ask me to vote according to my Catholic principles?
Our nation's founders sought to «separate church and state» in the sense of prohibiting the establishment of any particular denomination as the nation's official religious body, not in the sense of prohibiting religious organizations from addressing matters of grave importance to human welfare.
Our faith, based on Sacred Scripture and the teachings of religious leaders and saints throughout the centuries, has clear principles on how to achieve justice, peace, and human dignity for all. Furthermore, the Catholic moral tradition is grounded in natural law, which applies to everyone, not just Catholics.
What are the key principles that should guide us when entering the voting booth?
Four principles of Catholic social doctrine are key to making practical decisions that allow us to do good and avoid evil when voting: Promote and defend the dignity of the human person; support the family and subsidiarity in local, state and national institutions; work for the common good where human rights are protected and basic responsibilities are fulfilled; and act in solidarity with concern for all as our brothers and sisters, especially the poor and the most vulnerable.
Is there anything that Catholics should always reject?
As Catholics, «we can choose different ways of responding to pressing social problems, but we cannot disagree on our moral obligation to help build a more just and peaceful world through morally acceptable means, so that the weak and vulnerable are protected and human rights and dignity are upheld» (FC, 20).
Our faith reminds us that we must always reject and oppose intrinsically evil actions of any kind. Acts such as taking the life of an innocent human being are so reprehensible that they are incompatible with love for God and neighbor.
For this reason, the Church firmly opposes abortion and assisted suicide (euthanasia). In both cases, the lives of the weak and vulnerable are endangered, and there is no valid reason to allow the taking of innocent lives or to vote in favor of laws that permit these acts. Likewise, our Church opposes other actions that violate human dignity and are destructive to life, such as human cloning or destructive research involving human embryos.
The Church condemns genocide, torture, attacks against civilians in acts of terror or war, and racism, as these also constitute grave violations of human rights and human dignity. Other related concerns include excessive consumption of material goods, unjust discrimination, and the increasingly restrictive redefinition of religious freedom.
If all of these are priorities, which is the most important?
All these issues are important, but not all are morally or ethically equivalent. «The direct and intentional destruction of innocent human life from the moment of conception until natural death is always wrong and is not just one issue among many. It must always be rejected» (FC, 28).
At the same time, issues such as war, the death penalty, racism, and care for the poor and immigrants are of paramount importance. «These are not optional concerns that can be ignored» (FC, 29).
But if we must take all these principles into account, will there be anyone we can vote for?
Unfortunately, we are often forced to choose between two inadequate and flawed political agendas. It can be quite difficult to find candidates who align with our conscience on all key moral issues.
Therefore, the virtue of prudence is essential when voting. This virtue helps us reflect on the options before us, to determine, in light of the Church's teachings and our conscience, who most deserves our support. In other words, in a world of imperfect choices, we must strive to make the best possible decision.
Where Catholics must agree is on that fundamental moral obligation we share: «to help build a more just and peaceful world by morally acceptable means, so that the weak and vulnerable may be protected and human rights and dignity defended» (FC, 20).
If no party or candidate in a given election aligns with our fundamental Catholic principles, what should we do?
It is clear that one cannot vote for a candidate who advocates a policy that promotes an intrinsically evil act, such as abortion, euthanasia, assisted suicide, deliberately subjecting workers or the poor to inhuman living conditions, redefining marriage in a way that violates its essential meaning, or racist behavior, if the voter intends to support that position (FC, 34, emphasis added). But neither can one use a candidate's opposition to such evils to justify indifference or neglect of other important moral issues that affect human life or dignity (FC, 34).
There may be times when a voter chooses a candidate with an unacceptable stance, but this can only be done for «truly grave moral reasons,» not for partisan or personal interests. It may involve the prudent judgment that a candidate seems less likely to cause harm or to pursue other positive priorities.
If, for a serious reason, we vote for a candidate whose positions contradict fundamental moral principles, we have a duty to voice our opposition to those positions. Writing letters, participating in forums, and collaborating in local political activities are ways to firmly affirm our Catholic values.
There may even be times when some Catholic voters feel the need to take the extraordinary step of not voting for any candidate (FC, 36). This, too, is a serious decision that must be guided by conscience and the moral teachings of our faith.
What can I do to prepare to vote?
Learn about the teachings of the Church. The Catechism of the Catholic Church is an excellent starting point. Consider meeting in a small group to discuss Church teachings related to the candidates or their proposals.
Learn about the issues. Read the Catholic press and listen to the candidates. Find out what the candidates' positions are on crucial moral and social issues.
Seek the opinion of Catholics whom you respect.
Pray. Take your hopes, worries, and concerns to the Lord and ask for His guidance.
This seems difficult.
In today's political landscape, voting as a Catholic is a challenging task. It requires deep reflection, knowledge of Church doctrine, and awareness of the candidates and their positions on various issues.
The Church invites us to vote for what is best for society and all its members, especially those with fewer resources to express themselves or defend themselves. The great privilege of democracy lies in the fact that, as citizens and believers, we can influence the course of our country by voting for the common good; this is both a right and a responsibility. The great privilege of being Catholic is having a community of faith and a body of teachings, which goes back to Christ himself, that helps us make good decisions at the ballot box.
–Greg Erlandson is an award-winning Catholic editor, journalist, and publisher. Lori Dahlhoff, PhD in Education, has over 20 years of experience in catechetical ministry.





